This fact leads to situations where surrogate decision makers must fill the role of the patient in terms of making preferencebased treatment decisions, oftentimes in challenging situations where prognosis is uncertain. Making decisions about lifesustaining medical treatment in. Medical decision making for patients who lack decision making capacity and who have no surrogate decision maker. In most states, the default surrogate decision maker for adults is normally the next of kin, specified in a priority order by state statute, typically starting with the persons spouse or domestic partner in jurisdictions that recognize this status, then an adult child, a parent, a sibling, and then possibly other relatives. Endoflife decision making for unborn and newborn infants. Pdf legal fundamentals of surrogate decision making. In this book, the authors, both professors of philosophy and members of the presidents commission on medical ethics, set out a theoretical framework for deciding who is competent to make his own life. Patient autonomy is a guiding principle in medical ethics, and respecting autonomy is a.
This is basic reading for those interested in mostly current ethical conceptualizations of surrogate decision making. Part i develops a general theory for making treatment and care decisions for patients who are not competent to decide for themselves. Advance directives, substituted judgment, and best interest all have limitations that constrain their usefulness when making medical decisions for patients who cannot choose for themselves. Mercurio, md, ma, faap overview participants will discuss the application of widely accepted principles of medical ethics in. By incompetent, this chapter is referring to decisionmaking competence as is necessary for the idea of informed consent. The decision making processes we choose will reflect choices among a number of ethical principlesthose specifying the purpose of substituted judgment, those guiding the surrogate decision maker, and those used. It is essential to assess the facts of the particular case and consider the states case law. Reconceptualizing the experience of surrogate decision making. It has thorough explanations of guidance principles, along with ways they should practically be applied, how they compete with each other, and what their drawbacks are. He received his phd from the university of north carolina at chapel hill in 1975. Awareness of these limitations allows us to shift attention to other observations that may provide guidance when patients cannot make their own decisions. Deciding for others studies in philosophy and health policy. After all, cases are usually controversial precisely. It also makes an enormous contribution to current scholarly debates regarding surrogate decision.
The literature of bioethics offers three different models for thinking about surrogates who make decisions on behalf of patients who cannot decide for themselves. Deciding for others studies in philosophy and health. Moreno, ethics deciding for others has much to teach the general reader who may have read press coverage of major court descisions such as cruzan. He taught at the university of arizona, the university of wisconsinmadison, and the university. Surrogate decision making jason lesandrini executive director of medical and organizational ethics wellstar health system. Aug 24, 2017 these findings suggest a discrepancy between the normative ethical framework of surrogate decision making and the descriptive reality of how it is actually being carried out. In their book on surrogate decision making, buchanan and brock said it well. The ethics of surrogate decision making, by allen e. If a patient is unable to make decisions for themselves about personal care, some agent must make decisions for them.
I argue that none of these practices are currently aligned with respectful treatment of vulnerable individuals. Volume 16, number 2 the journal of clinical ethics 127 deciding for others at the end of life. It also makes an enormous contribution to current scholarly debates regarding surrogate decision making in medicine, law, and ethics. Recently, proxy or surrogate decision making regarding the termination of lifesustaining interventions for incompetent patients has been widely endorsed and promoted. Some features of this site may not work without it. The ethics of surrogate decision making studies in philosophy and health policy by buchananbrock isbn. This is basic reading for those interested in mostly current ethical conceptualizations of surrogate decisionmaking. Patient preferences and surrogate decision making in. May 01, 2009 two standards should guide surrogate decision making. The problem of decisionmaking capacity in patients with dementia, such as those with early stage alzheimers, can be vexing. After all, cases are usually controversial precisely because reasonable. There is a substantial consensus among ethicists that harm is the central moral concept when judging the appropriate threshold for state intervention in parents medical decisionmaking. View or download all content the institution has subscribed to.
Second, it leads to behavior that is intolerant and polarizing. Publications and materials of the bioethics research library. These findings suggest a discrepancy between the normative ethical framework of surrogate decisionmaking and the descriptive reality of how it is actually being carried out. Appealing policy proposals often lose their luster once they enter the real world. The ethics of surrogate decision making, cambridge university press, cambridge 1989. The earlier the conversation begins, the longer both the family and providers have to prepare. After the cruzan decision and the patient selfdetermination act of 1990, many states enacted proxy statutes specifically for health. A surrogate decision maker, also known as a health care proxy or as agents, is an advocate for incompetent patients. Alternative models of surrogate decision making may mitigate this disparity by employing a valuebased approach over a strict prioritization of patient preferences. Consent and surrogate decision making special subjects. He taught at the university of arizona, the university of.
Surrogate decisionmaker an overview sciencedirect topics. On abortion, capital punishment, surrogate decisionmaking. Is it always in best interest when surrogates decide for patients who are. A similar learning curve can be expected for the ppp. The question is not whether the patients quality of life is below average, or worse than it used to be, or anything of the sort. Storytelling and moral agency mark yarborough prologue countless times every day, in hospitals across. However, dissension among authorized decisionmakers merits further counseling or consultation with an institutional ethics committee or similar resource. Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public. As it relates to endoflife decision making for infants, the law is rarely black and white. Default surrogate decision making fundamentals msd.
Digital citation created by the national reference center for bioethics literature at georgetown university for the bioethicsline database, part of the kennedy institute of ethics bioethics information retrieval project funded by the united states national library of medicine. On one hand, surrogate decision makers help physicians in taking. Ama code of medical ethics opinions on patient decision. The ethics of surrogate decision making, the authors do a thorough job of describing a framework to consider how to ethically treat incompetent patients and honor their selfdetermination. Goal setting, decisionmaking, and implementation of a plan of action by means of a shared, deliberative process. Exploring the application of ethical principles in pediatrics christy l. Deciding others ethics surrogate decision making political. However, patients frequently are unable to participate in decision making about their treatment because of the effects of the illness, treatment, or underlying condition. The ethics of surrogate decision making, cambridge. Third, appeals to the best interest standard are often vague and indeterminate. If there is a durable power of attorney for health care, the agent appointed by that document is authorized to make health care decisions within the. In the neuroscience intensive care unit nicu, most patients lack the capacity to make their own preferences known. Medical decision making for patients with neither decision making capacity nor a surrogate decision maker presents an ethical challenge for healthcare providers because there is no way to obtain informed consent for treatment.
Medical decisionmaking for patients with neither decisionmaking capacity nor a surrogate decisionmaker presents an ethical challenge for healthcare providers because there is no way to obtain informed consent for treatment. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our privacy policy. The ethics of surrogate decision making studies in philosophy and health. Should age be a deciding factor in ethical decision making. Duke professor of philosophy at duke university and also professor of the philosophy of international law at the dickson poon school of law at kings college, london.
Autonomy, beneficence, and the rights of parents and children. Decision making for incompetent elderly people is an increasingly serious issue for american society. Deciding what to dopresented on september 11, 2009 at the united nations, new yorkthe nour foundationblackfriars hall, oxford universitygeorgetown university symposium seriestechnology, neuroscience, and the nature of being. Alternative models of surrogate decisionmaking may mitigate this disparity by employing a valuebased approach over a strict prioritization of patient preferences. Law, ethics, and the patient preference predictor the. Unrepresented patients are individuals who lack decision. Such consultation is also advisable if a patients decisionmaking capacity, a surrogates authority, or the ethical or legal appropriateness of a particular treatment decision is disputed.
One is brought back to questions such as, does what occurs at fertilization make a moral difference, and if so, why. Considerations of meaning, morality, and transcendencetoward a common morality. Ethical roles and limits of surrogate decision making. The ethics of surrogate decision making and coedited from chance to choice. We argue that the best interest standard for surrogate decisionmaking is problematic for a number of reasons. As sulmasy and sugarman point out in regard to surrogate decision making, theoretical approaches are not useful in the clinical setting if they are impossible to carry out. Aboriginal, torres strait islander and other first nations people are advised that this catalogue contains names, recordings and images of deceased people and other content that may be culturally sensitive.
In chapter 2 of buchanan and brocks deciding for others. Indeed, as rid and wendler point out, enthusiasm for advance directives and surrogate decision making dissipated after years of implementation and study revealed deficiencies in those approaches. In chapter 2 of buchanan and brock blog 5 in chapter 2. Reconceptualizing the experience of surrogate decision. Article information, pdf download for surrogate decision making for unrepresented. Medical decisionmaking for patients who lack decisionmaking capacity and who have no surrogate decisionmaker. The ethics of surrogate decision making cambridge, uk.
Some surrogate decision makers may confuse their own or others interests with the. Bioethics research library of the kennedy institute of ethics. This book is the most comprehensive treatment available of one of the most urgent and yet in some respects most neglected problems in bioethics. Patient autonomy, assessment of competence and surrogate decision making. Overriding parents medical decisions for their children. If the patient does not have decisionmaking capacity, such as a person with dementia, in which case a proxy, or surrogate decisionmaker, must be found 2. In chapter 2 of buchanan and brock blog 5 in chapter 2 of.
Surrogate decisionmaking it is well established in medical ethics, practice, and law that the informed consent of competent patients must be secured before treatment. Moral diagnosis of the problems posed by the case and options for resolution 3. Decision making for incompetent elderly people is an increasingly serious. When discussing the ethics of overriding parental decisionmaking, it is crucial to clarify exactly what type of overriding is being proposed. Surrogate decision making when patients are lacking in decisional capacity, we depend on others to make decisions for them.
Surrogate decision making for unrepresented patients. The ethics of surrogate decision making, cambridge university press, cambridge, uk. Decision making for incompetent elderly people is an increasingly serious issue. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Genetics and justice, both published by cambridge university press. This issue brings together essays on topics that have been the subject of longstanding debate in the journal of medicine and philosophyabortion, capital punishment, surrogate decisionmaking, and genetic enhancement. Two standards should guide surrogate decision making. This surrogate decision maker may be formally appointed by the patient e. First, reliance on the best interest standard is subjective. A lack of decisionmaking capacity with inadequate time to find an appropriate proxy without harming the patient, such as a lifethreatening emergency where the patient is not conscious 3. Goal setting, decision making, and implementation of a plan of action by means of a shared, deliberative process.
1119 316 1240 808 1271 215 1474 18 1125 789 1184 654 971 717 635 434 460 360 958 799 601 732 1496 797 44 43 325 476 281 164 1500 1310 782 1341 236 1521 404 692 1258 1401 367 883 1113 572